Interpretations B and C both focus on the power of Elizabeth.
How far do they differ and what might explain any differences?
Interpretation B
An extract from an article entitled ‘The Indomitable Female Fortress: Queen Elizabeth I’, published in 2013 on the Women’s Media Centre website. The Women’s Media Centre is an American organisation which aims to promote women’s stories and roles.
Elizabeth I has always inspired me and reinforced the idea that women can do anything despite opposition. She was a successful monarch who, against all odds, led her country to a golden age while battling against the acute disadvantage of being a woman. In a time when gender inequality was widely accepted, Elizabeth I was a strong monarch who was able to control her subjects. She was determined to remain free from any man who would inevitably seize hold of her power over England. While other European female monarchs often had little political power, Elizabeth took centre stage by carrying out all the duties of a ruler, while neglecting the feminine duties of marrying and producing heirs. She did this to protect her power.
Indomitable means someone who is difficult to defeat or conquer.
Interpretation C
An extract from an interview with historian Anna Whitelock about the Tudor monarchs, broadcast on a 2021 podcast called ‘History Hit’. Anna Whitelock is a historian who specialises in researching the British Monarchy, especially the Tudors.
Elizabeth I does not deserve her reputation. Her role and significance in things like the defeat of the Spanish Armada have been entirely overstated. There was instability across her reign as she dithered about marriage candidates and about the execution of Mary Queen of Scots.
By 1580, she was an old, childless, unmarried Queen, which was not a position of strength. It was at this time that the people around her tried to put a positive spin on her position, calling her the ‘Virgin Queen’, making a virtue out of what was essentially a weakness. The main task of any monarch was to provide an heir and Elizabeth didn’t even try. Elizabeth is seen as the poster girl of Tudor monarchy but she ultimately failed; she allowed the throne to pass to the King of Scotland and the Tudor monarchy died out with her.